You're tuned to the good stuff
Who's More Over Their Ex?
The setup
The funny people
Meet the cast. 4
Say it with us
Highly quotable.
You just have to have an ounce of dignity.
Nothing complicated about it. You are alone, Julian.
Nobody wins. There's no way to win this game.
The premise
Here’s the bit.
A smug host welcomes Amy and Julian to a game show about getting over a breakup. Amy insists she and Aiden are only on a break after she overreacted to him kissing someone at a party, while Julian claims he's thriving since Maggie moved to San Francisco and plugs his new social networking app. In the opening round each waits for a call from an ex, and Julian grabs his phone first, only to find the host on the line. The challenges get crueler: Amy can't chat with her friend Melanie without fishing for news about Aiden, Julian is told to set his relationship status and can't bring himself to admit he's alone, and news of a fire several blocks from Aiden's place becomes Amy's excuse to check on him. In the final round both are sealed in glass booths with a famous breakup ballad and a slice of carrot cake; Julian sobs into the cake and Amy wins, but her prize is Aiden himself, and when she throws her arms around him the host declares she has failed the last test. Aiden leaves with Melanie, Amy retreats to the cake, and the host admits the game was never winnable before signing off with a plea of his own to his ex.
Behind the scenes
The people who made it.

Ryan McFaul
Director
Director of Season 2, Episode 10 "Slut-Shaming" (IMDb lists him as the episode's sole director).
A little extra
Notes from the archive.
The final round plays Bonnie Raitt's 1991 ballad "I Can't Make You Love Me" inside the contestants' glass booths.
Script
Automatically generated script; wording may contain errors. Speaker labels are inferred.
- 00:01
Game Show Host
Welcome to Who's More Over Their Ex, the game show where two contestants compete to prove they're doing totally fine. Let's meet our players, Amy and Julian. Come on out, guys. Welcome to the show. No. Amy, tell us about your relationship.
- 00:14
Amy
Oh, well, actually, Aiden and I aren't broken up, broken up. We're just kind of on hiatus because he made out with somebody at a party in front of me, and I totally overreacted. I mean, I tried to apologize, but it was too late. I already made things super weird.
- 00:28
Game Show Host
Pathetic. Julian.
- 00:28
Julian
Oh, uh, story's a little different. I was about to propose to Maggie, who wouldn't, right? And then she, uh, decided to move to San Francisco. But it's cool. I have my own things going on. You know what I mean? I developed this new social networking app. It's called Klooper, and, uh, you'll be hearing about it.
- 00:45
Game Show Host
No, I won't. Let's play. Contestants, you will now receive a phone call from your ex. Whoever holds out the longest without picking up plays first.
- 00:54
Amy
He looks like Aiden.
- 00:55
Game Show Host
Not even remotely. Remember, all you have to do is nothing. You just have to have an ounce of dignity.
- 01:07
Julian
Hey, are you in town or...
- 01:09
Game Show Host
You fool. It was me.
- 01:11
Julian
Is she with you?
- 01:12
Game Show Host
No, she's not with me. She's in San Francisco having the time of her life. You're with me in this room. Amy, you've got control of the board. Hit that button to select your challenge.
- 01:22
Speaker 1
Mutual friend. Mutual friend.
- 01:24
Game Show Host
Okay, Amy. Your challenge is to have a conversation with a mutual friend of Aiden's and not ask about him. Let's bring out your friend, Melanie.
- 01:32
Amy
Mel?
- 01:33
Melanie
Hey.
- 01:34
Amy
What's up?
- 01:35
Melanie
Nothing. Hungover.
- 01:37
Amy
Ugh.
- 01:37
Melanie
What'd you get into last night?
- 01:39
Amy
Um, popcorn, home, you.
- 01:41
Melanie
Some party in Greenpoint.
- 01:43
Amy
Uh-huh. Did you get with Kelly or...?
- 01:46
Melanie
Yeah.
- 01:48
Amy
Was Aiden there?
- 01:50
Melanie
Yeah.
- 01:51
Amy
Okay, what was his vibe like? Like, did he seem sad or...?
- 01:54
Game Show Host
Disappointing. All right, Julian, you've got control. Hit that button.
- 02:00
Speaker 1
Change your status.
- 02:01
Game Show Host
Okay, Julian, your challenge is simply simply to change your online relationship status.
- 02:06
Julian
Okay. Piece of cake. No problem. We're just gonna change that to, it's complicated. Hear me out.
- 02:15
Game Show Host
Nothing complicated about it. You are alone, Julian. Amy, hit that button.
- 02:20
Amy
Oh!
- 02:21
Speaker 1
No excuses.
- 02:23
Game Show Host
All right, Amy, your challenge is to hear a piece of information that could be used as an excuse to reach out to your ex and not act on it.
- 02:30
Amy
Oh, not a problem.
- 02:31
Game Show Host
It shouldn't be, but here we are. There was a fire four blocks were two blocks and two avenues away from Aiden's house yesterday.
- 02:38
Amy
The thing with this particular one is that he walks to work that way sometimes, so I feel like I should probably just step out and call and make sure he's okay.
- 02:46
Game Show Host
Actually, you know he's okay because he was at that party in Greenpoint. You really need to pull yourself together. You're embarrassing yourself on television. All right, it's time to play the final round.
- 02:56
Game Show Host
Contestants, please step into the nostalgia chamber. Your challenge is to hear the song I Can't Make You Love Me by Bonnie Raitt and Not Cry or Eat Carrot Cake. Are you ready?
- 03:09
Julian
Uh, can we do a different song?
- 03:10
Game Show Host
No. Play the song.
- 03:26
Game Show Host
Julian's crying and eating cake. Amy, that makes you our winner. Step on out of there. Congratulations. Your prize is Aiden. You win your ex back, Amy.
- 03:35
Amy
Oh, my God, baby, I miss you so much.
- 03:39
Game Show Host
Ooh, sorry, Amy, but that was your final test. You're not over your ex. tough break,
- 03:48
Speaker 2
yeah, sorry about that.
- 03:50
Game Show Host
Julian, you don't win either. Nobody wins, there's no way to win this game. Well, that's all the time we have. Tina, if you're watching, give me a call anytime. you, I love you, this is all for you.
The rabbit hole continues
One more couldn’t hurt.
More from across the archive.










