You're tuned to the good stuff
Cast List 2
The setup
The funny people
Meet the cast. 16
Say it with us
Highly quotable.
Don’t read into this.
No lines. I like that for you.
The premise
Here’s the bit.
Students waiting to learn their roles in Grease try to win over Mr. Koenig, whose favoritism makes every conversation feel like an audition. His former student Casper now helps run the production, while the choreographer and choir teacher add their own demands. By the time the list is ready, the students have endured insults, demonstrations and a reminder of who really holds the power.
Behind the scenes
The people who made it.

Mikey Day
Writer

Streeter Seidell
Writer
A little extra
Notes from the archive.
A sequel to the 2019 cut-for-time sketch “Cast List,” with Will Ferrell returning as Mr. Koenig and Mikey Day returning as Casper.
Script
Automatically generated script; wording may contain errors. Speaker labels are inferred.
- 00:01
Shannon
Oh, I'm so, I'm just so stressed, you guys. Like, I really want a good part in the spring musical.
- 00:07
Madison
I know. Lunch is almost over, and Mr. Koenig still hasn't posted the cast list. What's taking so long?
- 00:13
Amy
It's Grease, Madison. There's, like, a ton of speaking roles.
- 00:16
Madison
Ugh, I'm freaking out.
- 00:17
Lexi
Okay, Marcy, distract us. Make us laugh.
- 00:19
Marcy
Uh, me watching a Jacob Elordi movie? Uh, girl voter.
- 00:28
Mr. Koenig
Look at Look at you all, buzzing about like flies to fresh caw-caw.
- 00:37
Lucas
I love your outfit, Mr. Koenig. I wish I dressed as cool as you.
- 00:41
Mr. Koenig
Lucas, if you're going to stick your nose that far up my ass, at least check my colon for polyps.
- 00:47
Oliver
How's the cast list coming along?
- 00:52
Mr. Koenig
Slowly. This show needs to be a hit after the fall musical flopped. But I still contend that doing the color purple with an all-white cast was brave.
- 01:04
Mr. Koenig
Anyway. Anyway, I wanted to let you know that the school board is pressuring me to cast one particular student. I won't say who, but I'm wheelie, wheelie mad about it.
- 01:17
Amy
Oh my god! Do you think he's talking about me?
- 01:27
Theater student
Don't get in your head
- 01:27
Dyson
God, I'm so scared I'm going to get put in the chorus.
- 01:31
Oliver
What are you talking about? You always get the lead, Dyson.
- 01:34
Dyson
Yeah, but ever since I booked that Honey Nut Cheerios commercial, Mr. Koenig's been, like, weirdly jealous and mean to me.
- 01:41
Oliver
Whoa! Be careful what you say, okay? There's a rumor Mr. Koenig likes to watch us spin out through that Wicked poster.
- 01:49
Lexi
I I don't care what part I get as long as it's not a tree. I've been a tree the last five years.
- 01:58
Theater student
You're a senior, Lexi. There's no way you're gonna be a tree.
- 02:03
Speaker 1
Casper! Casper! Casper!
- 02:06
Casper
Don't ask me about the cast list, guys. Guys, you know the teacher's assistant isn't allowed to say anything. Lexi, Mr. Koenig wants to get a picture of you. Can you do me a favor and hold these?
- 02:19
Casper
Don't read into this. Don't read into this. Can you hold them high, please? Can you sway in the breeze a little bit? Yay! Excellent. Thank you.
- 02:36
Lexi
I can't be a tree again!
- 02:38
Casper
You don't know that, Lexi! You don't know that!
- 02:41
Mr. Koenig
Ola! Ola, I just had a few questions before I finalized the cast list is that okay mr. Hollywood or do I need to go through your agent
- 02:53
Dyson
I don't have an agent I just ate cereal in the background of that commercial I had no line sir
- 02:59
Mr. Koenig
hmm no lines I like that for you now Tyler
- 03:05
Tyler
yes mr. Koenig
- 03:07
Mr. Koenig
you're you're in the mix for Danny Zuko but I don't know if audiences are ready to accept a ginger as a leading man would you be willing to dye your hair black
- 03:20
Tyler
of course
- 03:21
Mr. Koenig
all of your hair
- 03:24
Tyler
whatever it takes sir
- 03:26
Mr. Koenig
gracias Shannon what are you doing here you're one of those weird Christian teenagers and there's kissing in this show would you even know what to do
- 03:39
Shannon
I know how to French. I know how to French kiss watch. Oh, yeah.
- 03:44
Mr. Koenig
Stop.
- 03:44
Shannon
I know how to French kiss, watch. Oh, yeah.
- 03:46
Mr. Koenig
Stop. I've seen worse. Oliver. Lucas. Oliver.
- 03:53
Oliver
Yes, Mr. Koenig.
- 03:55
Mr. Koenig
You're both up for the role of Knicky. But I'm worried you're too dorky and awkward to bring the raw masculinity the role demands. Casper, show them what an alpha male sounds like.
- 04:05
Casper
Yes, Mr. Koenig. I can show you the world. Harold, Shining, Shimmering, Splendid.
- 04:14
Marcy
Uh, girl boner!
- 04:18
Mr. Koenig
Exactly. Why did you have to graduate? Why? Madison?
- 04:24
Madison
Yes, Mr. Koenig?
- 04:26
Mr. Koenig
I want you for Sandy, but she's chesty. Would you be willing to wear a push-up bra with water balloons in it?
- 04:33
Madison
I'd be honored, sir.
- 04:34
Mr. Koenig
Wonderful. To quote the great William Shakespeare, "'Sluts with teats put butts in seats.'"
- 04:43
Mr. Koenig
And that just leaves the two jocks who have to do the show for elective credit. Could you two handle leading roles?
- 04:52
Basketball player
Nah, we gotta make most of rehearsals.
- 04:53
Basketball player
Yeah, because we got basketball.
- 04:57
Mr. Koenig
That only makes me want you more. One last thing. What was it? Oh, the show is cast.
- 05:05
Speaker 1
I god! Oh my god!
- 05:08
Casper
have tissues if anyone cries. Maybe you should hold them. and I'm sorry.
- 05:16
Speaker 1
Oh my god!
- 05:23
Mr. Koenig
Back up! Back up! Back up! Give me room. The choreographer must initial the list first. Channing! Channing! Channing!
- 05:51
Mr. Koenig
Let's get you home, baby.
- 05:52
Mr. Koenig
And and of course, our music director and choir teacher, Ms. Peebles.
- 06:06
Ms. Peebles
Things A couple of about me. and me. First of all, some people say that I'm too handsy with boys. That's a lie. I don't know who started it. And number two, I am tough as nails. But guess what? I get results. Watch this. You with the striped shirt. Come here. Sing me the highest note that you can.
- 06:43
Ms. Peebles
Oh, come on. You can do better than that. Tummy in. Yeah. Oh, you got nice ass. Ass out. And You gotta scrunch those up!
- 06:56
Mr. Koenig
That's nice! That's what we're talking about! Doggies, come get your treat! What is it, Shannon?
- 07:15
Shannon
Casper got Danny Zuko, he's not even-
- 07:19
Casper
Sorry guys, that's just showbiz.
- 07:22
Ms. Peebles
Oh my gosh, look at them! They're so bad!
- 07:28
Mr. Koenig
Bad? Don't you mean wicked?
The rabbit hole continues
One more couldn’t hurt.
More from across the archive.






















