Sarah Sherman plays Jewish Elvis, who performs at a retirement home for a group of elderly Jewish women. The sketch plays on the historical fact that Elvis Presley's maternal grandmother was Jewish. Jewish Elvis delivers a sultry, gyrating performance that drives the elderly women wild with excitement. Austin Butler, the episode's host (who played Elvis in the 2022 biopic), appears as one of the elderly women named Lois, breaking character of the other cast members with his over-the-top reactions. The sketch builds to a chaotic crescendo as the grandmas lose their composure over Jewish Elvis's provocative performance, with jokes about moisture, cream cheese, and retirement home life mixed with Elvis-style showmanship.