Shot in classic black-and-white cinematography reminiscent of 1940s-50s films, this sketch parodies "It's a Wonderful Life"-style Christmas redemption scenes. Austin Butler plays Rich, a drunk workaholic who has an emotional epiphany about wanting a family when he peers through a window at what appears to be a perfect family scene. However, the family inside - Steven (Andrew Dismukes), Janine (Heidi Gardner), their children (Sarah Sherman and Marcello Hernandez), and Janine's sister Denise (Chloe Fineman) - reacts realistically to the creepy stranger staring at them through their window. The sketch brilliantly contrasts Rich's melodramatic self-reflection (complete with mid-Atlantic accent and theatrical gestures) with the family's increasing terror and discomfort. At one point, Rich angrily yells at his own reflection in the window while the family watches in horror. The family speaks through clenched teeth to maintain their composure while discussing how to handle the "pervert" at their window. The sketch ends with Mikey Day appearing as Jimbo, an angel figure, giving Rich his epiphany. The humor comes from showing the uncomfortable reality from the family's perspective, subverting the classic Christmas movie trope.
