The CollegeHumor cast gathers at a bar to discuss the true meaning of Christmas. Each cast member has their own perspective - from Jesus and the nativity, to Santa Claus and gift-giving, to spending time with loved ones during the cold winter months. As they debate and argue over their various interpretations, the mysterious bartender who has been silently cleaning glasses throughout their discussion reveals himself to be Jesus Christ in robes. Just when they think they'll finally get the definitive answer, the sketch takes an unexpected turn. The video features recurring CollegeHumor in-jokes, including references to Mike Trapp killing Pat (a recurring character) and Grant's "too much milk" gag. The sketch is framed by narrator voiceovers mentioning Jack Frost at the beginning.