Doug (Ryan Gosling) and Gina (Vanessa Bayer) arrive at a neighborhood holiday party and immediately demand to meet the real Santa Claus. When the hosts reveal that Santa has already left, Doug becomes increasingly aggressive and threatening, insisting that Santa must still be there. As the sketch progresses, Doug's behavior becomes more menacing and violent as he refuses to believe Santa has gone, yelling at the confused party guests and making everyone extremely uncomfortable. The dark comedy builds as Doug's Christmas obsession spirals out of control.
