A heavy metal/industrial band called Titanica visits their biggest fan, Adam, at his home after he attempted suicide by jumping into a vat of acid after hearing their song "Try Suicide". The visit becomes increasingly awkward as the band members must contend with Adam's severely deformed body (described as looking "like a wet cigar") and his insistence that he wants to spend time with them on tour. The sketch is a dark comedy parody of cases where heavy metal bands were blamed for their fans' self-destructive behavior. After the visit, the band creates a song and music video called "Try Again (Adam's Song)" directed by fictional director Famous Mortimer.





| Person | Role | |
|---|---|---|
| Troy Miller | Director | |
| John Moffitt | Director | |
| Bob Odenkirk | Writer | |
| David Cross | Writer | |
| Jay Johnston | Writer | |
| Brian Posehn | Writer |